So, who do you think would play a good Sherlock Holmes? I have my idea pic inside...

[M. Clyde Pittman]

I have been writing a screenplay based on "The Valley of Fear" for over two years; so I have often wondered whoI would insert to play the roles of Mr. Holmes as well as Watson. Dozens of potential candidates have poured through my mind, and for some reason I keep coming back to Hugh Jackman. Physically, I think he captures the Conan Doyle Holmes pretty damn well. I don't think he is the greatest actor in the world, but I get the feeling he would thrive in the character.

Take a look at the picture, what do you think? Also, I'd love to hear who you think could play such a legendary character well...

[Sherlock Wood]

I personaly think that David Tennant would be perfect for this role. Hugh Jackman would be good but... David better. David has the look, the peronality, everything.

[Sujeet Jaydeokar]

That was just what I was thinking. David Tennant is very versatile and has that sharpness of feature one associates with Sherlock Holmes. Hugh Jackman should be good. I always thought Richard E Grant as possible Holmes or possible Dr Who.